Post-national urbanity beyond (pluri)nation(al) states in the EU: Benchmarking Scotland, Catalonia, and the Basque Country

Igor Calzada


This article compares three small, stateless, city-regional nation cases: that of Scotland, Catalonia, and the Basque Country after September 2014. Since the referendum on Scottish independence, depending on its unique context, each case has engaged differently in democratic and deliberative experimentation on the ‘right to decide’ its future beyond its referential (pluri)nation(al) states in the UK and Spain. Most recently, the Brexit referendum has triggered a deeper debate on how the regional and political demands of these entities could rescale the static nature of these (pluri)nation(al) state structures, and even directly advocate for some sort of ‘Europeanisation’. Based on a broader research programme comparing city-regional cases titled Benchmarking City-Regions, this paper argues that the differences in each of these three cases are noteworthy. Yet, even more substantial are their diverse means of accommodating smart devolutionary strategic pathways of self-determination through politically-innovative processes, which include pervasive metropolitanisation responses to a growing ‘post-national urbanity’ pattern emerging in the European Union. Thus, this article examines the following questions: (1) To what extent are the starting points for ‘smart devolution’ similar in each case? (2) What are the potential political scenarios for these entities as a result of the de- or recentralisation strategies of their referential (pluri)nation(al) states? (3) What are the most relevant distinct strategic political innovation processes in each case? Ultimately, this paper aims to benchmark how Scotland, Catalonia, and the Basque Country are strategically moving forward, beyond their corresponding (pluri)nation(al) states, in the context of the new so-called post-national urbanity European geopolitical pattern, by formulating devolution, and even independence, in unique metropolitan terms.

Paraules clau

right to decide, political innovation, small stateless city-regional nations, smart devolution, self-determination, democratic experimentation

Text complet:

19-31 (English)


Agnew, J. (2015). Unbundled territoriality and regional politics. Territory, Politics, Governance, 3(2), 119‑123. doi:10.1080/21622671.2015.1031580

Avery, G. (2014). Independentism and the European Union. Brussels: European Policy Centre.

Alcantara, C., Broschek, J., and Nelles, J. (2015). Rethinking Multilevel Governance as an Instance of Multilevel Politics: A Conceptual Strategy. Territory, Politics, Governance, 4(1), 33‑51.

doi: 00.1080/21622671.2015.1047897

Barber, B. (2013). If Mayors Ruled the World: Dysfunctional Nations, Rising Cities. New Haven: Yale University Press.

Barceló, M., Corretja, M., González, A., López, J., and Vilajosana, J. M. (2015). El derecho a decidir: Teoría y práctica de un nuevo derecho. Atelier: Barcelona.

Basta, K. (2015). Whatever the result of the Catalan elections, both Catalonia and Spain are now entering uncharted territory.

Accessed on the 3rd of April 2017 at Post-national urbanity beyond (pluri)nation(al) states in the EU: Benchmarking Scotland, Catalonia, and the Basque Country

BBC News (2014). Scotland Decides – Scotland Votes No. Accessed on the 3rd of April 2017 at

BBC (1955). The Land of the Basques by Orson Wells [vídeo]. Accessed on the 5th of April 2017 at

BBC Radio 4 (2015). The Invention of Spain. Accessed at

Bourne, A. K. (2014). Europeanization and Secession: The Cases of Catalonia and Scotland. Journal on Ethnopolitics and Minority Issues in Europe. 13(3), 94‑120. Accessed on the 3rd of April 2017 at


Brenner, N. (2009). Open questions on state rescaling. Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society, 2, 123‑139. doi: 10.1093/cjres/rsp002

Brenner, N. (2014). Implosions / Explosions. Berlin: Jovis. Accessed on the 7th of April 2017 at

Cagiao, J., y Ferraiulo, G. (2016). El encaje constitucional del derecho a decidir: un enfoque polémico. Madrid: Catarata.

Calzada, I. (2014). The Right to Decide in Democracy between Recentralisation and Independence: Scotland, Catalonia and the Basque Country. Regions, 296(4), 7‑8. doi: 10.1080/13673882.2014.11431613

Calzada, I. (2015a). Benchmarking Future City-Regions beyond Nation-States. Regional Studies Regional Science, 2(1), 350‑361.

doi: 10.1080/21681376.2015.1046908

Calzada, I. (2015b). Postindependence. San Sebastián: Translokal Academic Entrepreneurship.

Calzada, I. (2017). Benchmarking City-Regions. Regions and Cities Series. London / New York: Routledge. Work in progress.

Calzada, I., and Bildarratz, J. (ed.). (2015). Political Innovation: Constitutional Change, Self-Government, The Right To Decide & Independence. San Sebastián: Translokal Academic Entrepreneurship.

Castells, M. (1996). The Rise of the Network Society. Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell.

Colomb, C., Bakke, K., and Tomaney, J. (2014). Shaping the Territory in Scotland, Catalonia and Flanders (Working Paper, 5). London: UCL European Institute.

Connolly, C. K. (2013). Independence in Europe: Secession, Sovereignty and the European Union (Report for the US Department of Justice). Duke Journal of Comparative & International Law, 24, 51‑105.

Corijn, E. (2009). Urbanity as a Political Project: Towards Post-national European Cities. En L. Kong, y J. O’Connor (eds.), Creative Economies, Creative Cities: Asian-European Perspectives, GeoJournal Library, 98,


Crameri, K. (2015). Do Catalans have ‘the right to decide’? Secession, legitimacy and democracy in twenty-first century Europe. Global Discourse, 6(3), 423‑439. doi: 10.1080/23269995.2015.1083326

Friend, J. W. (2012). Stateless Nations: Western European Regional Nationalisms and the Old Nations. Palgrave: Macmillan.

Geoghegan, P. (2015). The People’s Referendum: Why Scotland Will Never Be the Same Again. Edinburgh: Luath Press Limited.

Goodwin, M., Jones, M., and Jones, R. (2012). Rescaling the State: Devolution and the geographies of economic governance. Manchester: Manchester University Press.

Guibernau, M. (2013). Secessionism in Catalonia: After Democracy. Ethnopolitics: Formerly Global Review of Ethnopolitics, 12(4), 368‑393.

doi: 10.1080/17449057.2013.843245

Harrison, J. (2010). Networks of connectivity, territorial fragmentation, uneven development: the new politics of city-regionalism. Political Geography, 29(1), 17‑27.

Hazell, R. (2015). Devolution and the Future of the Union. London: The Constitution Unit – UCL.

Hennig, B. D., and Calzada, I. (2015). In Focus: Regions between Recentralisation and Independence. Political Insight. 6(1), 20‑21.

doi: 10.1111/2041‑9066.12083

Herrschel, T. (2014). Cities, State and Globalisation: City-Regional Governance in Europe and North America. Oxon: Routledge.

Herrschel, T. (2015). The Metropolitanisation of Nationality? City-regions, autonomy and the territorial state. Politics in Spires. Accessed on the 6th of March 2017 at

Herszenhorn, D. M, and Burchard, H. von der (24 of January 2017). President of Catalonia Vows to Go Ahead With Independence Vote. Politico. Accessed on the 10th of April 2017 at

Jonas, A., and Moisio, S. (2016). City regionalism as geopolitical processes: A new framework for analysis. Progress in Human Geography, 1‑21.

doi: 10.1177/0309132516679897

Katz, B., and Bradley, J. (2013). The Metropolitan Revolution: How Cities and Metros Are Fixing Our Broken Politics and Fragile Economy. Washington, D. C: Brookings Institution Press.

Kay, J. (2009). The economics of small states. Edinburgh: David Hume Institute.

Keating, M. (2017). Contesting European regions. Regional Studies, 51(1), 9‑18. doi: 10.1080/00343404.2016.1227777

Keating, M. (2001). Plurinational Democracy. Stateless Nations in a Post-Sovereignty Era. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Keating, M., and Harvey, M. (2014). Small Nation in a Big World: What Scotland Can Learn. Edinburgh: Luath Press.

Keating, M. (1999). The Politics of Modern Europe: The State and Political Authority in the Major Democracies. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

Khanna, P. (2016). Connectography: Mapping the Global Network Revolution. London: Weidenfeld & Nicholson.

Martí, D., and Cetrà, D. (2016). The 2015 Catalan election: a de facto referendum on independence? Regional & Federal Studies, 26(1), 117‑119. doi: 10.1080/13597566.2016.1145116

Moncusí, A. (2016). ¿Comunidades imaginadas a contracorriente? La proyección política de los nacionalismos, en cuestión. Debats. Revista de cultura, poder y sociedad, 130(1), 19‑30.

Moreno, L. (2015). Catalonia’s in(ter)dependence and Europeanization (Working paper, 7). Madrid: Instituto de Políticas y Bienes Públicas (IPP) CSIC. Accessed on the 3rd of April 2017 at

Moreno, L. (2016). Theory and Practice of Paradiplomacy: Subnational Governments in International Politics. Regional & Federal Studies, 26(2). doi: 10.1080/13597566.2016.1157072

Morgan, K. J. (2013). The Rise of Metropolitics: Urban Governance in the Age of the City-Region. In N. Bradford and A. Bramwell (ed.), Governing Urban Economies: Innovation and Inclusion in Canadian City-Regions (p. 297‑318).

Toronto: University of Toronto Press.

Muro, D., and Vlaskamp, M. C. (2016). How do prospects of EU membership influence support for secession? A survey experiment in Catalonia and Scotland. West European Politics, 39(6), 1115‑1138.

doi: 10.1080/01402382.2016.1149993

OECD (2015). The Metropolitan Century. Understanding Urbanisation and its Consequences. París: OECD Publishing. doi: 10.1787/9789264228733-en

Ohmae, K. (1995). The End of the Nation State. London: HarperCollins Publishers.

Park, B. G. (2017). New spatial readings of the state. Territory, Politics, Governance, 5(1), 1‑4. Accessed on the 5th of April 2017 at

Passi, A., and Metzger, J. (2017). Foregrounding the region. Regional Studies, 51(1), 19‑30. doi:10.1080/00343404.2016.1239818

Politics in Spires (2015). Between Independence & Re-Centralisation: Political Innovation in an Age of Devolution. Accessed on the 5th of April 2017 at

Requejo, F. (2015). National Pluralism, Recognition, Federalism and Secession (or Hegel was a clever guy). In A. Gagnon, S. Keil, and S. Mueller (eds.), Understanding Federalism and Federation (p. 157‑176). London: Ashgate.

The Economist (19 of November 2016). The New Nationalism. Accessed on the 4th of April 2017 at

Sassen, S. (2002). Towards post-national and denationalized citizenship. In E. F. Isin, and B. S. Turner, Handbook of citizenship studies (p. 277‑292). London: SAGE Publications. doi: 10.4135/9781848608276.n17

Scott, A. (2001). Global City-Regions. In A. Scott (ed.), Global City-Regions: Trends, Theory, Policy (p. 11‑30). Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Serrano, I. (2013). Just a matter of identity? Support for independence in Catalonia. Regional & Federal Studies, 23(5), 523‑545.

doi: 10.1080/13597566.2013.775945

Uriarte, P. L. (2015). El Concierto Económico Vasco: Una visión personal. Concierto Plus. Post-national urbanity beyond (pluri)nation(al) states in the EU: Benchmarking Scotland, Catalonia, and the Basque Country

Washington Post (2017). Independence movements are a sign of European strength, not discord. Accessed on the 7th of April 2017 at

Enllaços refback

  • No hi ha cap enllaç refback.